I was on 580 CFRA with Steve Madely this morning. You can listen here.
FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE: ProWomanProLife condemns decision to honour Dr. Morgentaler
PWPL’s official press release on the matter of Morgentaler and the Order of Canada.
And it is done
Morgentaler has his Order of Canada.
Time for the other members of goodwill to give theirs back as Jon Kay suggests they might in this piece.
Conferring such a prestigious award on Dr. Morgentaler would be a huge mistake — one, I expect, that will be greeted by the clink-clink of dozens of current OC holders returning their medals and pins. One wonders whether the Order of Canada would ever reclaim its former prestige.
Top ten things to know if Morgentaler gets the Order of Canada
10. Can there be any debate? Once and for all, Canada’s elite are pro-abortion.
9. Canada’s elite can teach you how to think. It’s amazing. We are all unconflicted about abortion now.
8. When said elite knows there will be a public outcry and condemnation of honoured person in question, they’ll choose to bestow that mighty honour on a day when the better part of the country has escaped all modern communication, preferring instead to sit with a beer by a lake somewhere. Heck, even I almost missed this one, and I care deeply about this issue. My fellow Canadians are smart—a beer by a lake sounds perfect. In perpetuity. (Why oh why is the per cent of voters declining?)
7. The Conservative Party of Canada doesn’t care one bit about this issue.
6. Abortion is not private. The Order of Canada takes the thing to a whole new public level.
5. Men certainly can speak out on abortion—Morgentaler has and boy, did it ever work.
4. Canada is not as tolerant as we’d like to believe. (The essence of this award is to stick it to those across Canada who remain rightly conflicted on the topic of abortion.)
3. If enough Canadians protest an award, the person in question will most certainly get it. I am going to nominate—and then vociferously protest—someone I like.
2. Getting the Order of Canada is now officially, not an honour.
1. Abortion is not a closed question. Hold on for the ride, folks—this one ain’t over til it’s over. When the pro-abortion elite in the Governor General’s office raise this issue over a Canada Day holiday, well, let’s thank them. Nothing is sacred now.
A doctor writes in
The entirety of this post is from a doctor who wrote in:
If Morgentaler gets this Order of Canada, it goes without saying that this is the greatest disgrace for this most prestigious award. However, the main issue at stake is that it makes abortion into something good. Until now, even for extremist pro-abortion people, abortion was seen as a tragedy where women had a choice to ‘terminate’ their offspring with the help of the medical profession. But now, it has been glorified to the point of making evil into good. Its main defender may be made a national hero.
How can I accept this? Impossible. I would share with you four episodes to which I was personal witness during my medical training.
You be the judge if they can be considered a good.
1) During one of my ICU rotations, a woman in her late seventies had just suffered a major medical crisis. She was very agitated, but we did not know why. We suspected it was her medical problem; however, the clinical signs did not fit together. I spent sometime talking to her and what she confided to me was she wanted to talk to a priest before dying. She then volunteered that while teenager she had had an abortion and she was very tormented by this. We managed to get her a priest and she was more at peace after that.
2) While doing outpatient medicine, I saw a single-African-Canadian mother. She was pregnant and she was asking for advice on how to handle her situation. I asked her if she wanted to keep the baby. She said this is what she wanted. I re-assured her that we were going to help her with her choice. I referred to our social worker. One week later when I returned to the clinic, I approached the social worker for follow up with the case. With a smile and beaming with pride, she said: “I convinced her to have an abortion and referred her to the abortion clinic..after all; this is the best choice for her.” I was left speechless.
3) Doing a chronic pain clinic, I saw a single-African-Canadian mother suffering from fibromyalgia. She was involved in a physically abusive relationship and she would not stop crying. The medical team was having hard time managing her pain, and the medical specialist made clear to us it was due to her difficult social situation. The doctor shared with us the story: she was pregnant and had two little girls at home but the boyfriend did not want the baby. So at 24 weeks pregnant she was referred to a tertiary care hospital for a late term abortion. First they killed the baby with medication and then they gave her inducers to deliver the body. She was waiting in her hospital room to start the ‘labor’ and then she needed to go to the bathroom. While in the bathroom, strong labor contractions ensued and the pain specialist then told us: “suddenly, the ‘thing’ felt to the floor and it was a boy”. Needless to say, the poor woman had been traumatized since then.
4) And the last one to illustrate that even pro-abortion people know what is wrong. One of my supervisors, staunchly anti-religious (especially anti-catholic), but otherwise very nice, shared with me the story of his wife aborting their first child who suffered from Down Syndrome. He admitted the experience had been harder for his wife than for him. Later, when his second child, a ‘normal’ daughter, was four months, she got really sick requiring intubation and ICU admission. There was a significant danger that she might be left with cerebral damage after this medical crisis. He told me: “it was as if the Universe was getting back to us for aborting our firstborn.”
Not my Canada, either
Re.: Morgentaler getting the Order of Canada–each question Douglas Farrow asks in this piece will hang over our heads for as long as he has this “award.” But I think the best question is this one:
Third, what business has the committee making such a controversial award, when it so gravely affronts a very substantial number of Canadians and, indeed, deeply offends their consciences? Some argue that this “brave” man must not be denied his reward for bringing down an unjust law restricting abortion. But many others argue that the real injustice is that Canada, thanks in large part to Morgentaler and his disciples, has no law at all against cutting up babies in the womb — indeed it is the only “civilized” country without such a law. Does the committee presume to settle this national argument for us? How else are we to read their decision to make the award? And what does that say about the state of democracy in Canada?
____________________________
Tanya adds: Democracy? Not sure. But this prestigious award is allowing itself to be surrounded by scandal and controversy. In what way does this tarnish the image of The Order of Canada?
If Morgentaler truly is recognized with the award, one thing is certain. He and all those routing for him should be reminded that the pride and satisfaction that normally come along with receiving the award should be denied.
For the first time in the Order of Canada’s history (as I understand it) the award will be presented without the unanimous approval of the committee. One shouldn’t even want to win it this way.
Someone is getting the Order of Canada tomorrow…
…and it looks like it could be Morgentaler. These rumours are floating around the web. Here’s some info behind the rumour.
On Friday, the Prime Minister’s Office (PMO) sent out “Order of Canada talking points” to Conservative Members of Parliament and said that tomorrow, June 30, the Governor General will issue new awards. Nowhere in that email did it say who will get an award, but sources tell me Dr. Henry Morgentaler will be among the recipients.
The talking points were meant to show process–how the decision works, and that Cabinet does not have anything to do with this decision. It sounds as though they are preparing for the pending outcry.
Many questions remain: Why now? Why not part of the official process back in February? Was protocol routed to do this? And finally, though I only chose to blog about this when I had confirmation from different sources, will it prove true?
Happy Canada day, all.
___________________________
Andrea updates: This is not a rumour. Morgentaler is definitely getting the Order of Canada tomorrow.
Order of Canada clear for 2008
Phewf. Dr. Henry Morgentaler will not be on the Order of Canada list for 2008. Good news.
But my letter was already written, so I thought I might as well post it. As a friend said recently, never miss a chance to express your opinion.
__________________________
Brigitte wonders: Missing a chance to express your opinion? What’s that like?
How to reach the Governor General
How and why: Here’s info on how to reach the Governor General so that you can express your concern about Dr. Henry Morgentaler being received into the Order of Canada.
If you are feeling keen, you could copy that letter to each of the following people who sit on the independent advisory council:
Beverly McLachlin, PC, Chief Justice of Canada, Kevin Lynch, clerk of the Privy Council and secretary to the Cabinet, Judith A. LaRocque, CVO, Deputy Minister, Canadian Heritage, Karen Kain, CC, chair, Canadian Council for the Arts, Yvan Guindon, CM, PhD, president, the Royal Society of Canada, Thomas D. Traves, chair, Association of Universities and Colleges of Canada, Patricia A. Baird, OC, OBC, professor emerita at the University of British Columbia, Daurene E. Lewis, CM principal of the Nova Scotia Community College Technology Campus, L. Jacques Menard, OC; chairman of BMO Nesbitt Burns, J.E. (Ted) Newall, OC chairman of Nova Chemicals Corp, Marie-Lucie Morin, Deputy Minister of Foreign Affairs and International Trade
Incidentally, that Globe and Mail poll never tipped in favour of Morgentaler, and was never published in the list of past polls.
____________________________
Clarification: Sorry, my post is not particularly clear. We know Morgentaler has been nominated and that the Governor General’s office has a file on him. The letters are to show there is a level of concern and controversy over his nomination and that Canadians are very much divided on this issue, thereby hopefully preventing him from being received into the Order.
Actions speak louder than words
Pro-abortion advocates were, so we were told, prepared to spur dialogue about Henry Morgentaler getting an Order of Canada. They were throwing protocol to the side, they wanted a public reaction to the idea. All in the name of an open, frank discussion, to be sure.
You recall the Globe and Mail poll asking whether Henry should be received into the Order of Canada. I voted, and waited to see the results. Which were never posted in the long line of “past polls.” So I found the old link and checked.
Those results were telling, and pretty devastating if you actually want Morgentaler to belong to the Order of Canada. Upwards of 80 per cent said no.
Now the poll is still open and the results remain unposted. The number of yes votes is slowly increasing. It’s at 10543 votes to the 55117 votes of the no side.
I think we all know these polls are not truly representative: Anyone can vote four times if they want. What these polls show is the level of interest in the topic, the passion, and just a gut reaction to the idea. And the gut reaction showed Canadians don’t want Morgentaler to belong to the Order of Canada.
I’m sure that in time, the pro-abortion side can bring the poll up to a 50-50 tie. Point is, they’ve had to work a whole lot harder to do so. One would assume, given the whole thing is their idea, that it would have been no problem. But Canadians are not passionately interested in this topic, they are learning, save for a couple of National Abortion Federation supporters sitting pretty. And those who are interested, say no.
This is not the way the Globe usually does polls. Perhaps they can’t bring themselves to post the result until they get it “right”. Perhaps a call for a frank, open dialogue on the topic only stands when the results are favourable, otherwise, not so much.
Keep checking here for the poll results.